Journalling

What is a prop firm trading journal?

By The Silo Team · Published · Updated

A prop firm trading journal is a trading journal that records every trade against the rules of the funded or evaluation account it was taken on: daily loss limit, maximum drawdown, profit target, minimum days. Where a generic journal asks "was this a good trade?", a prop journal also asks "how much of my rule allowance did this trade spend?" Silo, the trading journal for prop firm traders, is built around that second question.

The distinction matters because funded accounts do not usually die from bad analysis. They die from rule breaches. A journal that ignores the rules is auditing the wrong thing.

How is it different from a generic trading journal?

A generic journal is built around P&L and setups: what you traded, what it made, which patterns work. All of that still matters on a funded account. But the funded-account job adds constraints that change what a journal needs to measure, because on a rule-bound account a profitable day can still be a bad day.

  • Rule tracking. Every trade spends some of a finite allowance: daily loss, overall drawdown. The journal should show what each trade cost in rule terms, not just in money.
  • Drawdown awareness. Trailing drawdowns move as your equity does. Knowing your distance to the floor at the time of each trade is different from knowing your closed P&L.
  • Execution scoring. Breaches are usually preceded by behaviour: revenge entries, oversizing after a loss, trading past a planned stop point. A prop journal grades the behaviour, because the behaviour is what ends accounts.

None of this is exotic. It is simply what the job requires. If your capital carries rules, your record of that capital should carry them too.

What should a prop firm trading journal record?

Everything a normal journal records (instrument, direction, entry, stop, target, size, outcome in R, the setup it belonged to) plus the rule state around the trade. In practice that means a few extra fields per trade and a few per day.

  • Per trade: how much daily loss allowance remained before entry, and how much the trade could have consumed at the stop.
  • Per day: distance to the drawdown floor at the open and the close, and how close the worst moment of the session came to it.
  • Per phase: progress to target against days remaining, so you can see whether you are earning the target or starting to force it.
  • Per decision: a one-line reason for anything that deviated from plan: moved stop, added size, skipped a valid setup.

Written down like this it sounds like bookkeeping, and by hand it is. Silo does the rule maths automatically: you set your account’s rules once in Prop Challenge Mode, and every journalled trade updates your remaining allowances. On Pro and Elite, trades arrive automatically via MetaTrader API import from MT4 or MT5; every plan can import a MetaTrader Excel report or the CSV template.

Why not just review P&L?

Because P&L hides the thing that matters most on a funded account: how close you ran to the line. Two traders can finish a week identically green while one of them spent a morning within a few ticks of a daily loss breach. P&L review scores them the same. A rule-aware review does not, and the trader who keeps seeing breach-adjacent sessions in their record has been warned by data, not by a blown account.

This is what The Verdict exists for in Silo: a daily execution score that grades rule adherence, playbook deviation and overtrading, separately from the money. It is available on every plan, alongside the Cold Start Protocol: a pre-session checklist so each day starts with a stated plan rather than a reaction to the first candle.

Where should you start?

Start with the rules of the account you actually trade. Write them at the top of the journal, and record the rule state on every trading day for two weeks. Most traders find the first honest surprise quickly, usually how much of the daily allowance one loose session consumes. A journal cannot pass an evaluation for you, and no tool can promise that. What it can do is make sure the account you lose, if you lose one: teaches you something specific.

If you trade an FTMO account, Silo maps the Challenge rules directly onto your journal. FTMO trading journal

Silo has three plans, Basic, Pro and Elite, and every plan starts with a 7-day free trial. trading journal pricing