The Verdict: a daily score for how you traded
The Verdict is a feature of Silo, the trading journal for prop firm traders. At the end of every session it produces an execution score: a grade for how you traded that day, computed separately from your profit and loss.
A winning day can be badly traded and a losing day can be well traded. The Verdict exists to keep those two facts from blurring together.
// Last updated ·
What does The Verdict measure?
The Verdict grades a session on the parts of trading you control. It reads your journalled trades and scores the day across factors including:
- Rule adherence: did any trade breach or brush your configured account rules (daily loss, drawdown, size caps)?
- Playbook deviation: how many trades matched a setup you have defined, and how many were improvised?
- Sizing discipline: position sizes relative to your own plan, not a generic standard.
- Overtrading: trade count and clustering against your stated maximum for the day.
The score is shown as a full-screen end-of-session card, and it is shareable: a record of execution quality, not a P&L screenshot.
Why score execution separately from P&L?
Because P&L is noisy and execution is not. Over a handful of trades, luck moves the money number far more than skill does, but whether you followed your rules is binary and visible immediately. For prop traders, execution is also what the account rules actually test: a challenge is failed by breaches, not by low profits alone.
Scoring execution daily gives you a trend you can act on. A falling Verdict with flat P&L is an early warning; a rising Verdict during a drawdown is a reason to keep going.
How do prop traders use The Verdict?
- During an evaluation: review the week by score, not P&L, to catch breach-adjacent behaviour before it ends the account.
- Across multiple funded accounts: compare execution per account to see whether a rule set or market is degrading your discipline.
- With a mentor: share the Verdict card instead of screenshots. It shows process quality without exposing account details.
The Verdict: common questions
What is The Verdict in Silo?
The Verdict is Silo’s daily execution score. It grades how you traded (rule adherence, playbook deviation, sizing and overtrading) separately from what you made or lost that day.
Is The Verdict based on my profit?
No. It deliberately excludes market outcome. A profitable day traded outside your rules scores badly; a red day traded exactly to plan scores well.
Which Silo plans include The Verdict?
All of them: Basic, Pro and Elite. The shareable Verdict card is included on every plan too.
Can I share my Verdict score?
Yes. Each Verdict produces a shareable card showing the session’s execution score and its components, without exposing your account balance.
